Now would be an excellent time for California to buy the CVP.
ADDED 1/26: In 2010, the Little Hoover Commission proposed spinning off the State Water Project into its own agency (similar to the ISO for the electric grid, I believe). I’d suggest buying the CVP and putting both the projects under the same state agency, as the LHC suggested. Further, there is some urgency in doing this before Westlands gets a huge giveaway from their new friends in DC.
She says probably, but she has screwed the environmental water community fairly regularly. I don’t think her hold on the seat is nearly as secure as everyone says. She’s never in California and hasn’t been for years. There is considerable room for someone to run to the left of her. Any of the big names who wants that seat should run for it, especially someone with an environmental focus. She should have to campaign, and have to justify the water compromises she is willing to make. They aren’t appropriate from a Democrat.
I am consumed by the news about Trump and the election, which doesn’t leave me much spare capacity for thinking about water. I am heartsick about this reversal. I had genuinely thought I was seeing new forms of power (social media connectedness between clear thinkers and Science) come to the fore. I thought the old form of power (rich men buying access to political power) was on the wane. This may yet be true, but seeing the changeover pushed back several years has made me deeply sad.
Nevertheless, I have had a few spare thoughts and my poor blog is hungry.
Thought 1: Pretty wet start to the winter, which is nice. I had thought Drought Year 6 would be the year we got serious. But with the balance of power changed over, I’m just as happy for a wet year, a year when the water world goes about its business as usual, forgetting droughts ever happen.
Thought 2: I have no interest in the particular person in charge of Interior and Reclamation. I’m assuming all candidates will suck equally and see no need to try to forecast.
Thought 3: I am not sure that water policy will be the dominant force on CA agriculture this year. Immigration and labor could be big. But I’m looking hard at trade. Trump seems to be going out of his way to offend China and India, who are large markets for tree nuts. If Trump provokes a trade war, or a real war, with China, I’m thinking that this post of mine will seem prescient. Almond orchards are all the same asset; holdings in tree nuts are not a diversified portfolio. If there’s an overseas market bust, there will be an unbelievable surplus of harvested almonds, with more new orchards coming into bearing years. Although the instream flow proposals are being touted as a terrible pressure on northern San Joaquin Valley economies, after a China/India trade bust, it may be that land prices collapse and easiest ways to get flows back in the river are to simply buy up abandoned almond orchards.
UPDATE 12/21: Trade war with China.
Westlands Water District’s Johnny Amaral writes a response to Mark Arax in the Fresno Bee:
The article also criticizes an agreement between Westlands and the Obama administration. That agreement resolves a decades-long problem involving drainage facilities for the Central Valley Project, relieves taxpayers of billions of dollars of liability and requires Westlands to take over the responsibility to manage drainage in the future. Neither side got everything they wanted, but the process of negotiation worked.
At a time when many Americans are tired of the governments’ inability to work together to solve problems, this settlement ought to be treated as a model for how to get things done.
I should certainly hope not! I don’t like the terms of exchange, but those aside, this settlement is a terrible model for others. It has no terms for determining whether Westlands keeps its side of the bargain. It doesn’t establish a program for monitoring whether Westlands has fulfilled its duty to treat drainage, or set standards for treatment (salt concentrations, ppm) that Westlands must meet, nor set any remedy for what happens if Westlands doesn’t meet a standard. If Westlands doesn’t treat its drainage water adequately, what happens? Westlands gets no water the following year? Westlands pays a fine? The entire contract is nullified?
This settlement has no way to determine whether Westlands performs its side of the bargain, but of a certainty, Westlands will insist that the federal government performs its side. Bad bargain aside, this is a terrible model for acting in the public interest.
UPDATE: We are all set and grateful. Thank you!
I would like to join the protests against Trump on January 21st. Do I have any readers who could host me and a friend for the overnights on Jan 20 and 21st? We don’t need more than places to sleep. If you are willing, please email me at onthepublicrecord @ gmail . com.
I find the usual recommendations for grief a little silly, because my experience was that grief was the boss of me and decisions to do any particular thing never went anywhere. That said, yes, all forms of self-care are a good idea: yoga, meditation, exercise, hygge, journaling, being with your loves, being with animals, going outside. Sure. Do what you can manage.
Here is my realistic list of what you can do about grief:
- You don’t have to do anything. If you are healthy, grief will pass. Sleep. Eat what your body wants and sleep some more. Notice when you start to feel energized again.
- Give yourself permission to go small. For two years, I was a tiny person, with nothing left over to give to friends, no interest in anything abstract, no capacity to follow any plot beyond my own. It is OK to be that way for a while, and for healthy people, grief will pass.
- Give yourself permission to be OK sometimes. Grief comes in waves; between the waves you may feel good. That is also natural and fine. So is black humor. Do not waste energy on guilt for feeling good or for laughing at bleakness.
- If you weren’t healthy going into grief, jesus fuck go get help. This is time for therapy. Grief and its depression will find all of the unhealed places and re-open old hurts. Addicts are at very high risk of relapse during grief.
- Of the standard recommendations, I got the most from going outside and from getting a dog. I found myself compulsively driven to plant and garden, but I don’t know if that’s a widespread grief response.
- As an overarching guide, I found Ro Randall’s presentation of the tasks of grief much better than the mainstream concept of the stages of grief.
After your grief, this situation will still be astonishingly bad and we will still have to respond. I don’t mean to suggest anything different. But right now, grief is an additional burden, its own thing. Respect it; one way or another, grief will take its full toll. Also know that the part that is grief will pass. It just does.
Friends, I find this a bit bizarre and further, I dislike talking about myself here. This week, however, two of my strongest intellectual interests have converged. During the years this blog was silent, my partner and I were given cause for great grief. We were essentially obliterated; my absence from the blog I love is evidence of that. I was too reduced to have abstract interests, including water, but I read everything I found about grief. (I am also astonished that I didn’t find the work Dr. Kearns pointed me to, which is about the best I’ve read on grief.)
While reading about grief, I was substantially frustrated. In our state those years, everything was explainable by grief, which is essentially useless. I did not find the stages of grief useful either, especially when I was told they could intermix. I wanted to know what was natural to grief and would lift of its own, what was situational, and what was potentially pathological and should be addressed. This week, as we are back in grief, I’d like to sort it for you in more concrete terms. These are ways you are likely experiencing grief:
- That stoned numb feeling is grief. Clumsy, knocking into things, losing words, feeling disembodied –all grief.
- Your exhaustion is from grief. It isn’t just the time change, nor staying up to see the election results. Grief is exhausting and you need to sleep.
- Crying during transit. When you are grieving, you cry when you move between places. Driving, walking, even cycling all become times to sob.
- Appetite regression. The stronger the grief, the more the appetite goes back to childish foods. When we got our bad news, at first we couldn’t eat, then we ate nothing but breakfast cereal for days. Expect to crave the comfort foods of your childhood. I didn’t really love Didion’s book on grief, but she pointed to the most useful tip on grief I saw anywhere. Emily Post wrote:
“It is also well to prepare a little hot tea or broth,” Mrs. Post advised, “and it should be brought them upon their return without their being asked if they would care for it. Those who are in great distress want no food, but if it is handed to them, they will mechanically take it, and something warm to start digestion and stimulate impaired circulation is what they most need.” [Emily Post’s 1922 book of etiquette, Chapter XXIV, “Funerals”]
- Carbs. This is a peculiar observation and I don’t know the mechanism, but I can tell you for certain. Carbs are important right now; they are called comfort foods for a reason. If you restrict carbs in your diet, the depths of your grief will be deeper.
- Spontaneous crying. It is OK and appropriate. Do not be afraid; you will not cry harder than your body can take.
- The feeling of being encased in fog, or moving through a viscous fluid, or greyness or bleakness. This is grief-related depression. It should go away, but keep an eye on it.
- Low motivation, difficulty initiating movement and plans, fatigue that makes all functions hard. This is also grief-related depression. Frankly, we just submitted to it and did almost nothing.
If you are otherwise healthy, your grief will pass. It just does, lightening for small stretches of time that lengthen into days. You will know that grief has passed when intellectual interests return, when you find the energy to tackle something big you want to do, when you feel like your old self. When grief passes, we will all still face this incredibly horrible reality. But you will be assessing and participating in it with your usual capacities, without the incremental burden of grief.
UPDATE: I got some commiseration that makes me think that this post isn’t clear. We had a very bad couple of years, but have gotten much better. For two years we have been well and happy. The grief did indeed lift. This election knocked me down, but not nearly so far.